If you’re a recruiter, you’ve likely experienced the frustration of a lack of applicants, passive candidates ignoring your emails, and unanswered outreach attempts.
Passive candidates may not be actively job hunting, but they can still be interested in the right opportunity. However, expecting to engage them with just a single email is unrealistic. According to a report by Lever, a well-structured email sequence can increase response rates by up to 41%.
Recruiting is fast-paced, and candidate attention spans are limited. That’s why a strategic email sequence, rather than a one-off email, is essential for building meaningful connections. In this guide, we’ll explore how to reduce friction in outreach and successfully engage passive candidates with an optimized email sequence strategy.
Crafting Personalized Email Templates
Experienced recruiters know that a one-size-fits-all email never works. The content, tone, and timing of each email need to be tailored to different roles, industries, and candidate personas.
Key Elements of a Strong Email Template
•
Subject Line: Keep it short, clear, and include a personalized element (e.g., the candidate’s name or role) for higher open rates.
•
Customization Variables: Use placeholders for details like the candidate’s name, company, and location to make emails feel highly relevant.
•
Save Your Templates: Never lose a well-crafted email! Saving templates allows for easy reuse and iteration.
Each email should offer a different value proposition rather than repeating the same message. Otherwise, candidates may lose interest or mark your emails as spam.
Consider the Candidate’s Perspective
Every follow-up email should address why the candidate may not have responded:
•
Did they receive the email at the wrong time?•
Was the first email too generic or unengaging?•
Did they feel the role wasn’t relevant to their background?Each follow-up should be designed to counter these concerns and rekindle interest.
Example Email Sequence
A four-touch email sequence might look like this:
1.
First Touchpoint: Introductory outreach (presenting the opportunity).
2.
Second Touchpoint: Follow-up email (checking in, providing additional details).
3.
Third Touchpoint: Value-driven message (highlighting key job benefits or company culture).
4.
Fourth Touchpoint: Last attempt (addressing why they may not have responded).
By structuring emails in this way, you increase engagement without overwhelming candidates.
Pro Tip: Leverage TalentSeeker’s candidate activity insights to tailor emails based on recent updates to their projects or professional profiles.
Planning an Effective Email Sequence Schedule
Timing is a critical but often overlooked factor in email outreach. Sending messages at the wrong time can annoy candidates or land your emails in spam folders.
Best Practices for Email Timing
•
Avoid sending emails on public holidays.
•
Don’t send multiple follow-ups in a single day.
Spacing Out Follow-Ups
The optimal time between follow-ups is typically 3–4 days. Sticking to a schedule ensures consistency in outreach. For example:
•
First email: Sent on Monday at 6 PM
•
Second follow-up: Sent on Thursday at 6 PM
Spacing out emails prevents overloading the candidate while keeping your opportunity top of mind.
Another strategy is to gradually increase the gap between follow-ups:
•
2-day gap between Email #1 and Email #2
•
3-day gap between Email #2 and Email #3
•
4-day gap between Email #3 and Email #4
This pacing keeps the candidate engaged without being too pushy.
How Many Follow-Ups Should You Send?
If a candidate hasn’t explicitly declined, continue following up. Some responses may come after the 10th email.
Studies show that while the response rate for the first email is around 4.5%, sending up to 9 follow-ups can increase response rates to 22.37%—nearly five times higher.
Using Data to Optimize Outreach
To improve your email sequences, track these key performance metrics:
•
Open Rate – Are candidates opening your emails?
•
Click-Through Rate – Are they engaging with your CTA (Call to Action)?
•
Response Rate – Are they replying?
How to Troubleshoot Low Performance
•
Low Open Rate? → The subject line needs improvement.
◦
Make it more engaging, concise, and personalized.
◦
Studies show that personalizing subject lines can boost open rates by up to 50%.
•
High Open Rate, Low Click Rate? → Your CTA needs to be clearer.
◦
Ensure candidates immediately understand what action they need to take.
◦
Avoid multiple CTAs in a single email.
•
High Open Rate, Low Response Rate? → Your email content needs more candidate-centric messaging.
◦
Focus on what’s in it for them rather than just describing the company or role.
•
Still no improvement? → Your candidate list may be outdated.
Pro Tip: Use TalentSeeker’s talent search to access up-to-date candidate contact details.
Sharing Successful Sequences With Your Team
Top-performing recruitment teams share insights with one another. If a colleague’s email sequence is performing well, adapt it for your own use.
How to Leverage Team Collaboration
•
Duplicate high-performing email sequences and modify them as needed.
•
A/B test different messages to see what works best.
Pro Tip: Use TalentSeeker’s Good Fit/Bad Fit categorization to collaborate on candidate evaluation and refine outreach lists.
Leverage TalentSeeker for Smarter Talent Sourcing
Email sequencing is a powerful tool for candidate engagement, but the foundation of successful outreach is having the right candidate data.
TalentSeeker streamlines talent sourcing, project-based skill evaluation, and data-driven hiring decisions—allowing you to:
Access global talent pools with 300M+ professional profiles. Assess real project experience beyond just resumes. Optimize outreach with AI-powered insights.With TalentSeeker, you can connect with more candidates faster and more effectively.
Start optimizing your recruitment outreach today!